top of page

Digital Twins for Accountability with Hugh Dugan & Daniel Wagner

Ildiko Almasi Simsic
4 minutes ago
25 min read

Watch the episode


Summary

In this episode of The No Nonsense Sustainability Podcast, host Ildiko Almasi Simsic welcomes returning guests Hugh Dugan and Daniel Wagner to discuss the concept of digital twins for multilateral organizations. Dugan and Wagner bring their expertise from Multilateral Accountability Associates to explore how technology can enhance accountability in global institutions.

The conversation delves into the use of AI, blockchain, and zero-knowledge proofs to create digital twins that map decision flows and resource allocations in real-time. The guests discuss the challenges multilaterals face in adopting these technologies and the potential for constructive disruption in the sector.

The episode concludes with a vision for the future, where digital twins could transform accountability and efficiency in multilateral organizations. The guests emphasize the importance of transparency and independent verification to ensure these institutions meet their mandates and deliver real-world impact.


Highlights

  • Digital twins can map decision flows and resource allocations in real-time.

  • Zero-knowledge proofs offer a new way to verify spending without revealing sensitive data.

  • The Apollo 13 analogy illustrates the potential of digital twins for problem-solving.

  • Multilateral organizations are slow to adopt AI and blockchain technologies.

  • Constructive disruption is necessary to improve accountability in global institutions.

  • Digital twins could lead to a new field of 'accountability economics'.

  • The UN's lack of sunset clauses in mandates is a significant challenge.


Key takeaways

1. Digital twins can provide a real-time overview of multilateral organizations' operations and efficiency.

2. Zero-knowledge proofs allow for verification of financial transactions without compromising sensitive information.

3. AI and blockchain are essential for driving radical change in multilateral organizations.

4. Transparency and independent verification are crucial for holding global institutions accountable.

5. The concept of 'accountability economics' could redefine how we measure institutional success.


Timestamped breakdown

00:00 — Introduction and Guests: Host Ildiko Almasi Simsic introduces returning guests Hugh Dugan and Daniel Wagner.

01:51 — Defining Digital Twins: Hugh Dugan explains the concept of digital twins for multilateral organizations.

02:56 — Zero-Knowledge Proofs: Discussion on how zero-knowledge proofs can verify spending without exposing ledgers.

04:11 — Apollo 13 Analogy: Using the Apollo 13 mission as an analogy for digital twins in problem-solving.

06:40 — Challenges in Adoption: Exploring why multilateral organizations are slow to adopt AI and blockchain.

09:15 — Constructive Disruption: The need for constructive disruption versus traditional budget cuts.

15:58 — Accountability Infrastructure: Defining 'Accountability Infrastructure' and its role in multilateral organizations.

19:12 — UN Mandates and Sunset Clauses: Discussion on the lack of sunset clauses in UN mandates and its implications.

24:40 — AI and Human Diplomacy: Exploring the balance between AI capabilities and human diplomatic roles.

29:45 — Blockchain and Diplomacy: The role of blockchain in reducing 'useful ambiguity' in international diplomacy.

37:15 — Market Discipline and the UN: Comparing market discipline in the private sector to accountability in the UN.

40:30 — Vision for Success by 2027: What success looks like for digital twins and accountability by November 2027.


Edited transcript

Welcome back to the No Nonsense Sustainability Podcast. I'm Ildiko Almasi Simsic. This show isn't about saving the planet with corporate slogans or glossy brochures. We leave the PR spin at the door. We're here to talk about real communities, real projects, and the future we're building together with the people shaping it, and the critics testing it. Today, we're revisiting a topic from a different perspective, the new multilateralism. My guests are not new to the show. They're returning for the second time to talk about what has changed in a year.

Daniel Wagner is the CEO of Country Risk Solutions and the managing director of Multilateral Accountability Associates. He's been a director at CO28, worked at several multilateral development banks, advised governments and countries on cross-border risk, and has written 14 books at this stage. My other guest, Hugh Dugan, is the president of Multilateral Accountability Associates, a career diplomat who's advised 11 US ambassadors to the UN and served as senior director in the National Security Council. Welcome to the show. So, last time you were here, we were talking about your book about the new multilateralism and Multilateral Accountability Associates, which was at its early days then. Since then, everything has changed and full disclosure, I have joined MAA as an associate working mainly on AI and sustainability, which I'm very excited about. But let's get to the buzzwords because our discussion today will be very different from last time. So Hugh, why don't you start by explaining the title of the episode. What is a digital twin?

We're looking at defining accountability by a new metric by creating an opportunity for us to take an X-ray of a multilateral organization to see what's inside when it comes to efficiency, what is its potential, what is it realizing right now, and how we might train that muscle in a new way. Multilateral organizations are not for-profit industries. So we don't have the convenience of interest rates and stock prices and other financial metrics to gauge whether they're succeeding. So we have to look deeper into the organ itself through an X-ray of some sort or try to map its genomics so to speak to identify the potential that it has, whether it's realizing it or not, and where to place our expectations accordingly.

Okay, that's very neat. But I know this comes with a lot more technology. So then why don't you talk about what this zero-knowledge proof is that we have been discussing about digital twins?

Well, a zero-knowledge proof lets one party convince another that a statement is true while revealing nothing about the fact that it is true. As an example, to prove that you are 18 years old, your driver's license answers that question to the extent that it is not a fake ID. So today the options are trust us or show us everything. Zero-knowledge proof creates a third option. An institution can prove a budget line was spent as reported or that funds reached registered beneficiaries without publishing the ledger behind it. So in order to work, zero-knowledge proofs must sit alongside trusted data sources, audits, and background checks.

Yeah. So this is quite a pragmatic approach because previously we talked about more transparency, disclosing more things, more documentation, and now we're talking about how to use technology to actually bring that into life. What happened in this last year since Multilateral Accountability Associates were founded and how did you come to this technology conclusion to use it as a mechanism for accountability?

Well, I watched again the movie Apollo 13, and you might remember when Apollo 13 took place, the astronauts were stranded in outer space, and the only way to bring them home was for the ground crew in Houston to recreate the actual Apollo 13 capsule to identify what was in the capsule that they could use to jerryrig a way home. So they created what was a twin so to speak immediately on the ground of what was inside the capsule including tape and scissors and trying to repurpose some of the equipment for the sake of jerryrigging a means to get back home. So that was a twin and I thought well we should have a twin of the multilateral organization too, a digital twin because now we have that capacity with technology to map out the organization, its decision flows, its resource flows, its operational activities and try to then take that digital twin and do a bit of what if. What if it had less money, what would happen, what if it took decisions more quickly and try to create a simulation so to speak of the organization and probing what are its weaknesses and potentials in a new way. So I took this idea of twinning and thereby engaged now with modern information technology. We think we can create dashboards, so to speak, that simulate how the UN operates on a daily basis and then put some simulation to it and ask what-if questions and then retrieve data that would tell us certain outcomes or parameters that we could then log as a new database altogether, which would continue to grow and continue to help improve the what-if outcomes.

It seems very clear to us that there's no way that the multilaterals are going to be able to embrace radical change, which is what is required in the absence of embracing blockchain technology and AI. So, we're on the AI blockchain train, if you will, and our job is to help them basically embrace radical change and utilize these tools in order to achieve it.

No, I understand that the concept of digital twins is not new. Even the UN is talking about digital twins for cities, certain government bodies. So, they most certainly see the value of it. Based on your experience, do they disclose enough for you to be able to create such a digital twin?

I think what it does, it sets a new standard in the world. It can't be ignored. When the worldwide web became popular, the UN did not embrace it. In fact, it ignored it and a few UN secretariat employees, young people with a bit of imagination spent their own time after hours building the web page for the UN and one year later it became the most visited web page in the world. So, the UN will be compelled so to speak to join the rest of us. And I believe our approach to a digital twin technology which will also incorporate AI and other features will become more of a norm and the organization will be obsolete if it simply doesn't keep up with the times and create its own web page and engage digitally in a way that many other organizations will be doing sooner rather than later.

I think if we're looking at the IFI or the international financial institutions landscape, the World Bank is leading on providing APIs and data. Then how do you see the other IFIs disclosing information? Have you heard of any other initiatives where they want to do digital twins to see what the organization might be doing or should be doing better?

Well, as you well know, Ildiko, the multilaterals are kind of slow to embrace change and they're kind of slow to do things differently. There is some sign that a number of multilateral development banks are moving in that direction. They're not doing it quickly enough. And the problem is that the pace of change is so great that if they don't get on the train and start riding the train now in a serious way, they're just going to fall further and further behind. So what's really needed is for a mandate from the top to say we're going to start allocating funds for this purpose from the state going forward and we're going to continue to allocate more and more funds and do a better and better job of utilizing these tools for our good and the common good.

Yeah. And when we're looking at keeping these organizations accountable, enhancing transparency so we can measure what they actually deliver, the critics might hear this as a Dodge UN type initiative where you're coming in and bulldozing what was there before. What makes your approach radical but constructive compared to those other dodge type institutions?

Yes. I hear you loud and clear and perhaps we are being disruptive and maybe we're too much of a bull in a china shop. But if we look at how the UN has underperformed all its existence, but especially the last 5 years, things are actually getting worse. It's not as though the UN is keeping things where they are. There is more conflict in the world, more deaths. The realization of any of the strategic development goals is maybe 15% at best, and that's dropping every year because the nature of threats and challenges is growing more quickly and faster than the UN's capacity to respond to it. So, perhaps we are disruptors and I'm not afraid to break some China on the way and maybe have to fix it a little bit. But disruption is much less damaging than contentment. And the UN is content and the populations of the world think it's doing its job and they're content in their illusion that the UN is mattering. So the contentment is much more damaging than disruption.

The Department of Government Efficiency started with a verdict and went looking for savings. We start with a question. Did they do what they said they would and publish the answer? The decision to cut or merge or fund more belongs to member states. Our work could just as easily show that a program deserves money. So continuous machine-readable independent verification of whether mandates deliver results has never existed for multilateral institutions. The outcome has been predetermined.

Yeah. Our credibility rests on published data, open data, reproducible analysis and a right of reply for every institution before we publish.

Yeah. So, previously when we were looking at the evaluations of these organizations, they were largely self-audited and you know self-reported KPIs or information. If we are thinking about a constructive independent third-party watchdog organization, who are the likely candidates to fund this and why would they support such a thing?

Well, we want to remain independent and a strength of our approach is that it has a moat. We will not be taking money from an organization that we are assessing or from a government which has a political bias. We have identified revenue streams that will support us and I could identify one or two of them for you but we intend to remain independent and draw our finances from commercial sources. For instance, the database that we're going to create that could be very useful to philanthropies, to governments and others who could pay us a licensing fee to access our database. Others might want to take a look at our digital twin because it will be operating 24/7 and that could be a good reference point on any given moment as to what the UN is doing, whether its resources are being utilized efficiently, etc. Academia too will find I think our findings and our approach of use to their research. So we expect to be able to generate the revenue streams that will serve us well.

If you think about Bloomberg terminals, every desk trader on Wall Street has a screen in front of him and it's a separate terminal or it was for the Bloomberg Financial Information Network and Bloomberg wasn't being paid by Citibank or by Bank of America. He had subscribers to his service and that terminal is on every desk. If we need a terminal that can describe the efficiencies of multilateral organizations or let's say even philanthropies, any organization that doesn't operate on a for-profit basis needs to show efficiency and effectiveness anyway and we want to establish so to speak an equivalent of a Bloomberg terminal for multilateral organizations and draw subscriptions and other means of resources for us.

We want realistic funders such as foundations that already fund open data and fiscal transparency or a coalition of midsize donor governments that want value for their contributions. The institutions themselves paying for tools they use internally and paying for users of deeper analysis. Each carries a conflict which is why we want several. And there must be guardrails. No single funder above a capped share of revenue. No funder chooses targets or sees findings before publication. Every funding source is disclosed and an independent advisory board exists that can say no.

Yeah, that sounds like a very well-thought-out plan. In my line of work, I do work with digital twins for SCS 2050 but there it's primarily the governments themselves who want to know how they could work more efficiently and do things better so you know the little apps that we build model ministries and governments and increasingly more the World Bank and some of the UN but returning to the original idea of MAA who's currently around the table. What does it take to bring such an initiative, such a platform to life? How did the composition of the team change? What are the new sort of skills that you've identified as necessary?

We are looking at what we think are other actors in our strategic space and we don't find any actor that is going to have an independence mode or that has the objectivity or the commitment to use blockchain and other new technologies in a way where the findings will be permanently documented and not finessed later by some party for their political or commercial purposes. So, we found a unique niche, in fact, I believe we've created a new category, so to speak, of something I call accountability infrastructure, which is more than just reading the Wall Street Journal and deciding what company to buy and sell. It's going to have its own algorithmic intellectual property. We're going to have our own formulas whereby we take in what data we know about an organization and it's mostly qualitative data because as I say quantitative data is hard to come by. So we're going to create our own algorithms of sort and incorporate into this accountability infrastructure and I believe if you know we had more time and we were so inclined to talk more academically I think we're actually pioneering a new field of economics I'm going to call it accountability economics that incorporates these more qualitative aspects and applies them to institutions that have been elusive to measurements of most any sort.

We give our resources to the UN or to a philanthropy in good with good intentions with belief that it will be utilized in good spirit. That's all. I mean we really need more in this world to have the metrics that will tell us is that the most efficient place to put your charitable resources and if so then let's do that. If it's not the most efficient place what could make it more efficient. We also want to offer more than a report card. We want to be a coach in some ways and help these multilateral organizations find their ruby slippers and tell them how to use them.

When we started MAA about September of 25, we created a core team of people who had decades of experience in a variety of different categories related to multilateral institutions that can range from legal to financial to other functions which multilaterals find important. That said, what we decided to do this past summer was add to that team a bench of people who have great skill in the AI and data and blockchain arena. You're of course one of them. We also have entities in the software space, in the trust space, in the infrastructure space of building AI. So we're continuing to build the team and our plan is basically after the team has been more or less created to full complement as we see it for now by the end of the year we then will focus on operationalizing these new products.

Yeah, I think that is the mismatch in skills that usually hinders initiatives like this that you have the technical experts and the technology experts and there's really not much in between but I think we are lucky in a sense that we have a few of us that understands these institutions and also the technology of how to actually build that site because if we're looking at what already exists we know that the UN itself recognized the need to have some sort of an inventory of all of those thousands of mandates over the years, right? So, when you look up what the general assembly asked for and when they asked for it and what was delivered, that's where the transparency should be. But is this mandate registry enough of a transparency? Is it a good first step towards what you would expect from the UN?

The mandate registry is way overdue as a basic resource as a basic reference to the member states. They simply don't have an inventory of the thousands of mandates. And to complicate this question is that none of the mandates have sunset clauses. One or two or three or four maybe peacekeeping operations, but all of the others are not closed-ended. They don't say we will stop this exercise upon completion or by a date certain. So the creation of mandates is kind of what a diplomat at the UN is supposed to do. Diplomats negotiate. They like to get agreement. They're exhausted. They go home for Christmas. They are not experts in implementation. That's not part of their job description historically. They reach agreement and that's supposedly the end. So the agreement here though calls for activity to be implemented by and overseen by those same diplomats who are already taken up with next year's set of negotiations. So this implementation phase of UN and other multilateral mandates is often left just to the secretary general and his team and staff and they know that the diplomats are preoccupied with other things and that nobody is really taking them into account and again for 80 years we've been trusting their goodwill and we've been disappointed repeatedly on that basis. So we have to realize that the nature of diplomacy does include implementation or watchdogging and that's another key function that we expect MAA will be able to provide as a third party.

Yeah, I would add to that Ildiko that the UN's own mandate implementation review in July 2025 counted more than 40,000 resolutions, decisions, and presidential statements issuing mandates since 1946. In 2024 alone, the system supported some 27,000 meetings and produced about 1100 reports. There was no board, ministry, or newsroom that can read that, but machines can. The same review found that 85% of active mandates contain no instructions for review or termination. UN80, the General Assembly's follow-up work on the mandate life cycle and the multilateral development bank reform agenda are already asking the questions that MAA answers. Is this institution delivering what it was mandated to deliver?

Yeah. And it's really interesting to see how there's so many of these other vouch organizations and trackers, but they don't link the important aspect. They focus on either the climate finance, what was promised, but there's no follow-through and we don't really see what was promised, what was funded, what got done. And what's most concerning for me is we don't really see the evaluation. And when there is an evaluation, it often comes from the UN itself. So, how can it be judge and jury? And what do you think will be the most painful things to expose? Is it the amount spent or is it the results or the lack thereof?

I think the most disappointing thing is that commitments are made and they're not monitored or kept. We could focus all of our anxiety on the bricks and mortar UN and complain that people come to work at 10:00 instead of 9:00 in the morning and we could complain about overspending on frivolous things and first-class airfare. We'd like to go beyond that type of critical accountability and look at what about the commitments. Let's make that the subject of our analysis and take it off of an individual office and take our criticism away from the bricks and mortar because that hasn't worked all these years and I was there for 26 years and we tried that and we still try it and it doesn't deliver in the end and the entrenched system continues to win. So, let's look at commitments as our unit of analysis and we will find repeatedly that there's more promise and less delivery and the public feels that way but we want to be able to substantiate their concerns and substantiate their criticisms and provide some tools for the public and Congress and other stakeholders to utilize not just to complain but to perhaps put things in a better direction.

And when we're looking at the technology, is it realistic that these AI systems today read all of the UN resolutions and tell us exactly which mandate should be closed? Where does that human interaction with the machine come into place to define those trigger criteria for flagging mandates for closure?

I think AI gets us rolling. It's like trying to write a book. You're looking at the typewriter for that first page and it sits blank for a long time. AI gets the ball rolling. It provides at least the structure. It can't be perfect. It doesn't gather intent behind the words. Diplomatic language often has a certain subtlety that might be missed by AI. It's missed by humans often. So why should AI be any better? So, it's a way to get the ball rolling, to throw print on paper to help compose our thoughts perhaps, but not create them. And so I'm eager to be able to index and create categories of activities and help order this massive problem. When you're a child and you want to buy a pack of crayons, you know, you start with the eight-color pack. I was about 5 to 10 years old. I wanted the 64-color pack of crayons. And I wanted to be able to distinguish and to have at my fingertips more subtle means of coloring. And I think AI gets us on that way. We could start if it can give us the eight colors right away. It's up to me to fill in the gaps. And let's hope over time it will be able to get up to the 64-color box and maybe make our work a little easier, but it's always going to be up to human interaction. We will not be putting computers around the horseshoe table of the security council anytime soon. It will have to be human beings and that the human element will be identified is all the more critical because once the human is no longer encumbered with doing things that AI can do for us they can be relieved of that repetitive labor and I think the true human component the most powerful part of what we bring to anything will be much more evident and much more accessible to utilize at that time. So I don't feel as though AI is the answer to everything and I don't feel it's going to be a competitor.

I would add that we have limited time to put some safeguards around AI. We're not doing a very good job of it and at the pace that it is proceeding. It's not difficult to imagine that five or 10 years from now they will be smarter than we are. And it's not hard in my mind to imagine that there will come a time maybe not in the too distant future when AI is actually either at the table or running the table. Now we don't want to think about that but I think it's something we should consider in thinking about the question that you asked because if we're not thinking about that then we're going to miss something along the way. Because we have to be open to possibilities and be mindful of the rapid progression that AI is making.

And I know when we're working together we're planning for the future when we talk about trust verification and especially encryption so we're planning for that quantum computing where encryption that we use currently will not be sufficient then you've worked over three decades in political risk and country risk. What would it take for an institution to hand over all this data voluntarily for a watchdog organization for analysis?

Well, I think you could answer that by saying maybe in another lifetime. We're so far away from that at this point in time that it's hard to envision. But at the end of the day, I think it's inevitable that the NGOs and the watchdog organizations are, you know, they're serving such a useful purpose that instead of multilaterals simply holding up a yellow sort of yield sign or stop sign in front of them, that there should be a green go sign in front of them and say, "Come on, take a look at us here. We're going to open up our books. We have nothing to hide." The problem is that these are imperfect institutions as all institutions are and they're unaccustomed to having to answer to anybody. That's a big part of the reason why we're doing what we're doing. That needs to change. They are accountable to the peoples. They are accountable to their shareholders. And this veil of secrecy that continues to exist among the multilaterals, it can't continue. And I think there's also these good practices from other industries. You mentioned blockchain and I know for supply chain for materials you can literally trace a piece of leather back to the cow with the blockchain technology. How do you see blockchain being implemented in this initiative? Could you really trace the UN dollar to the clinic it was spent on?

I think blockchain offers us the resource of confidence that agreements reached will be honored. There will be less of an opportunity to go back and erase parts of an agreement or to usefully forget something. A lot of diplomacy depends upon useful ambiguity in an outcome. I want to hear what I need to hear and you need to hear what you need to hear and we all agree on a gray agreement. That might be going away. I believe blockchain is going to either reveal that ambiguity and the publics will be dissatisfied with it or it's going to require less ambiguity in answers and more accountability to the outcome which we can trace in the future back to when it was made. So there'll be less revisionist history being made by diplomats as they go in the future and more reliability upon what we did agree upon. So blockchain can be utilized in that way effectively. I don't think it will be a handcuff on us. We don't expect to be handcuffed by it. There'll always be a need for nuance in diplomacy for revisiting agreements. We are organic beings and things evolve and we can't be locked down so to speak to an agreement made in other times that is now obsolete. So that will be reflected in the record going forward. But to have a ledger account that most anyone can access I think is going to help with transparency and overall more confidence in the process.

So we have talked about the why and the how to do it. Now let's talk about what would it look like? What is the how do you imagine this platform working? You mentioned a little bit about providing services for other organizations in the form of data and analysis. What is the best case scenario that you see in terms of the vision for this platform?

Well, if things proceed as they should, there will come a time hopefully in the not too distant future while these organizations become accustomed to opening the books to wanting maximum accountability from themselves to delivering maximum value and accountability to their shareholders. And we don't want to sound like some radical NGO trying to find what these organizations did wrong and hold them accountable. What we want to do is we want to encourage them to want to do this rather than catching them in some kind of a mistake or a slip up. And if they come to realize that their own future ultimately depends on doing that because the funding levels are dropping, respect for the organizations, trust in the organizations is dropping. I'm sure they want to reverse that. So what we're saying is take a hard look at yourselves, be willing to embrace this radical change, open the books, make accountability your central mantra, and then the rest in theory should come naturally. That's not an easy thing to do admittedly. But if they come to realize that their own future, their own viability rests on doing this, that I think is the key.

The integrity of the organization is at stake. If it appears obsolete and is slow to embrace new practices, let's not just say technology, but just new practices, new protocols that enable stakeholders to have transparent insights. If it doesn't simply evolve like that, it becomes more of a museum on the East River than a vibrant institution. And something else will fill that void in its place. The internet has filled a lot of voids and it's created even larger spaces that are more purposeful that I expect the UN will realize if it goes down this corridor eventually it's going to turn right and left and it will discover new corridors on either side it could not have seen before and those are going to lead to I hope purposeful outcomes with real impact and mandate delivery much more rapidly than has ever been the case before and also less repetition of efforts and less repetition of mandates that seek to confuse and advantage for political purposes someone or another. So I think we'll see a flushing out of the system of some of the so to speak fraud in international operations as we've seen in the for-profit sector. With more information, economics depends upon something rare called perfect information. If we all have perfect information, our resources would flow to the most advantageous place for our satisfactions. And so I don't see why this wouldn't happen in the multilateral setting too once we establish the metrics and the parameters whereby one can ascertain efficiency and effectiveness.

Yeah, just by building our own little app and looking at the mandates and the overlaps, I could see how that could be useful for the UN itself because they are always talking about efficiency and there's finally someone doing it for them because I know their procurement practices take forever and they might not even get the right specification because they don't even know who to procure and how to manage that workflow because of this gap between technology and technical experts. So I definitely see how this platform with the algorithms and the analysis can be kind of a watchdog but a very friendly watchdog that maybe influence the way these organizations do their own monitoring and evaluation.

We expect to be the first movers in this realm and therefore we're very mindful of the need to create very thoughtful normative standards right away so that they become the operational basis for others trying to also incorporate accountability economics in their calculations of support and engagement with multilateral organizations. So we feel a certain responsibility to come out with the best thought-out normative standards to bring to the marketplace because we do believe this is a first mover opportunity in what is a white fields opportunity for commercial aspects as well. In terms of these platforms and these type of analysis being applicable to multilaterals or international financial institutions then how do you see them evaluating their own operations because from what I've seen at the World Bank most of it comes from internally even though they call it independent evaluation group but it's usually not done by external organizations. How do you see the UN and the World Bank being different in this respect?

Well, I'm not sure that they necessarily want to be different and I think there is a reason why they generally rely on internal resources and individuals in order to get these things done. As public as they are, as transparent as they are in publishing their data, there's still an unknown story. There's still something that the public may not know, particularly in how these organizations are run. And as we've seen with recent scandals in the public domain, there are lots of secrets in all these organizations. And sometimes these good news stories that portray themselves as being these, you know, magical organizations that can defy gravity. Well, they're just not. And they then come quickly falling to Earth. So again, I think these organizations have the power to utilize the information that is at their disposal internally to do whatever it is that they want. The question is how do they maximize the benefit for everybody? Again, I can tell you from my own experience, there's so much that goes on within these organizations that nobody in the public domain will ever hear about. In that regard, they're no different than a private sector organization. So if the private sector organization is incentivized by profit, what is the incentive for the public sector organization? It has to be to be true to their core values and what it is they're supposed to be standing for.

We're seeing right now a crisis with Nvidia this week, last week. And the market is disciplining it. Whatever you feel about what took place and whether or not it touches upon the merits of the business is a separate thing. The market is disciplining Nvidia and the market never disciplines the UN. The UN doesn't ever have to feel that scrutiny. So we are hoping we are planning that our effort is going to change the atmosphere that the UN lives in and when it starts to rain the UN's going to get wet and it's going to want to seek cover. Currently when it rains it doesn't seem to get wet and it seems to be able to ignore it and still get its funding next year. But we're going to see the international organization now being compelled to improve itself because the atmosphere that we're creating around it is let's hope as consequential as what Nvidia is feeling right now.

Yeah, that is very true. So if we make this podcast episode an annual thing and I ask you to come back 2027, November, December, what will success look like for you for the next 12 months to have our product launch, one or more of our products launch will be a core metric for us to determine whether we're achieving our own objectives in the manner in which we want to achieve them. Now this is not something that's going to happen in a day or a week or a month. It's going to take several months to get this up and running. But the where I hope we are in a year is that we are able to say that we have gotten at least one multilateral organization to want to do what it is that we're suggesting and to have adopted or be in the process of adopting one or more of the products that we will create.

I think in the technical sense what we'd like to see certainly within six months is our algorithmic standard coming up to a verification level that we can actually designate as useful and calculable and dependable for multilateral organizations. So in other words if you have Windows 1.0. Our algorithm right now is at like 0.9. We need to do the work inside of our formulations and our technical capacity to make our algorithm a 1.0 and then continue to build it out over time. With that 1.0 designation, that brings a sense of confidence and applicability in real world terms. And to get to that 1.0, we need to be able to validate our algorithm by third-party applications by others who are not in our house and to repeat our algorithmic output with dependability and without our biases. So we're looking to validate our formulas in a way that seem to stand on their own and be separate from any other interference political or commercial bias that might otherwise change outcomes.

Hugh, Dan, thank you for being here with me today and discussing this fantastic initiative we're working on together. I can't wait to see what it looks like in 12 months. It's a pleasure being with you, Ildiko, and thank you so much for your warm hospitality and your wonderful dialogue with us.

And thank you for listening. I hope you're as excited about digital twins and keeping multilaterals accountable as I am. We'll share all the links in the description so you can follow us and find out more about what we're doing. I'll see you next time.

Comments


bottom of page